Are you sure that you are in a magnetically clean location? Manmade infrastructure and even buried geology can bias the magnetic field. After the magnetic declination is accounted, does the seem to point at Polaris properly?
Scopes: Meade LS-8 ACF, Meade ETX-90RA, Coronado PST, 70 mm Refractor, and 1970's-era Tasco 4.25" reflector. Eyepieces: WO Binoviewer, 40 mm TMB Paragon, 30 mm GSO Superview, 26 mm Meade Super Plossl, 14 mm, 10 mm, and 6 mm Televue Radians, Baader Mk II 8-24 Zoom, 10 mm and 25 mm Celestron SMA, Accessories: Meade Zero Image Shift Motor Focuser & 2" Dielectric Diagonal, 2x Barlow, Rigel Quikfinder, Orion 2" Variable Polarizing Filter, JMI case, LG 8" Portable DVD/media Player for Astronomer Inside, Green Laser Pointer, Celestron Power Tank 17aH. Primary software: Stellarium.